Car Insurance Claim

Aftermarket Parts and Insurance Claims: A Guide for Florida Body Shops

For auto body shops across Miami, Hollywood, and the rest of Florida, navigating insurance claim repairs is part of daily operations. One of the most common challenges is deciding between OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts and aftermarket parts—especially when insurance companies are involved.

At Gold Coast Auto Parts, we work closely with Florida body shops to provide fast access to OEM and aftermarket parts, helping shops save time, reduce costs, and keep customers satisfied. Here’s what every body shop should know about aftermarket parts and insurance claims.


The Cost Factor: OEM vs. Aftermarket

  • OEM Parts: Typically 30–50% more expensive than aftermarket. Insurers often resist approving them unless the vehicle is new or under warranty.

  • Aftermarket Parts: Can save 20–40% per part, which is why insurance companies frequently approve them for claims.

  • Impact on Shops: Choosing aftermarket parts from trusted suppliers helps reduce cycle times and increase shop profitability.


Types of Insurance Coverage That Affect Parts

Not all insurance policies handle parts the same way. For Florida drivers, coverage often determines whether OEM or aftermarket parts are used:

  • Liability Coverage: Usually defaults to aftermarket parts to keep repair costs down.

  • Collision Coverage: May allow OEM parts, but aftermarket is often the insurer’s first option.

  • Comprehensive Coverage: Depending on the policy, insurers may approve OEM for newer vehicles.

  • OEM Endorsements: Some drivers pay extra for policies guaranteeing OEM parts only.

Tip for Body Shops: Always check the customer’s insurance policy before ordering parts—it saves time, avoids disputes, and builds trust with clients.

Check our Inventory


Filing Insurance Claims with Aftermarket Parts

When filing or processing insurance claims, body shops can streamline the process by:

  1. Documenting Damage Clearly: Photos and reports help justify part selections.

  2. Explaining Options to Customers: Transparency builds confidence—let them know when aftermarket is insurer-approved.

  3. Working with Reliable Suppliers: Quick access to the right aftermarket parts helps meet insurer deadlines.

  4. Keeping Records: Track part invoices to simplify reimbursement and minimize disputes.

Maximizing Aftermarket Insurance Coverage

For body shops, aftermarket parts can actually improve claim efficiency if handled correctly:

  • Partner with Trusted Suppliers: Not all aftermarket parts are equal—choose brands that meet OEM specifications.

  • Negotiate with Adjusters: Highlight the cost savings and equal performance of high-quality aftermarket parts.

  • Educate Customers: Show them the benefits of aftermarket parts—affordability, faster turnaround, and reliable performance.

  • Use Cost Savings as Leverage: Shops can improve margins by sourcing aftermarket parts at competitive prices.


Why Florida Body Shops Choose Gold Coast Auto Parts

At Gold Coast Auto Parts, we help body shops in Miami-Dade and Broward County succeed by offering:

  • ✅ OEM and high-quality aftermarket parts

  • ✅ Same-day and next-day delivery across South Florida

  • ✅ Competitive pricing to maximize insurance coverage budgets

  • ✅ Expert guidance to match the right part for each claim


Final Takeaway

Insurance claims don’t have to slow down your shop. By understanding cost differences, insurance coverage types, and how to maximize aftermarket approvals, Florida body shops can improve efficiency and profitability. With Gold Coast Auto Parts as your trusted supplier, you’ll get the right parts—fast, affordable, and backed by expert support.

Check our Inventory

Back to blog